![Phoenix Personal Injury Lawyer [Top Rated] | Gage Mathers Law Group](https://gagemathers.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/logo.png.webp){kind=logo}
Free Consultation (602) 258-0646
No Fee Unless You Win
No Fee Unless You Win
When you’ve been in a car accident, the recovery process can be drawn out and tumultuous. The last thing you want is a lengthy back-and-forth between insurance companies, questioning the validity of your story.
Ideally, the road to a settlement should be straightforward, but this isn’t always the case. Insurance companies are quick to scrutinize, and any moment that feels off can launch a deeper dive into what happened.
Among the most common reasons for car accident insurance investigations: conflicting information, suspicion of dishonesty, unusual injury claims and damage patterns, or post-accident behavior. Sometimes, the reason is as simple as a backlog of claims or a routine review.
No matter the reason, car accident lawyers in Phoenix are there to help if your claim starts to stall, helping you verify your story, build your case, and hold the other party accountable.
When insurance companies are investigating an accident, they rarely want to pay out what your injuries and damages are worth. This is why they’re always on the lookout for red flags and inconsistencies in the narrative. These may include:
Insurance companies aren’t always the bad guy, though. Sometimes, people exaggerate their injuries or blatantly lie about what happened. Not only is this bound to frustrate any insurance company, but it’s considered fraud and is illegal in many states, including Arizona.
These days, your social media can even play a role. Insurance companies will take a peek throughout the claims process, and anything that can portray you negatively runs the risk of casting doubt on your claim and harm your chances of winning.
| Reason for Investigation | What It Means | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| Conflicting Statements | Drivers’ accounts don’t match | Raises doubts about who is at fault |
| Damage That Doesn’t Match | Damage patterns don’t align with the described accident | Insurers suspect exaggeration or misreporting |
| Delayed Medical Treatment | Injuries are reported days or weeks later | Makes it easier for insurers to argue injuries weren’t caused by the crash |
| Gaps in Treatment | Missed appointments or inconsistent medical follow-up | Insurers may reduce payout, claiming injuries aren’t serious |
| Late Claim Reporting | Accident wasn’t reported right away | Suggests possible dishonesty or altered evidence |
| Suspicious Social Media Activity | Posts contradict injury claims or behaviors | Insurers use this to dispute damages or credibility |
| Prior Injury Claims | Past injuries similar to current ones | Insurers question whether the accident truly caused the harm |
Organized, detailed documentation makes a difference in building your case. The role of medical records in car claims, for example, is to reveal the extent of your injuries, your treatment plan, and your long-term recovery process. These are all key components to gauging the compensation amount to ask for.
When proving your case and avoiding an insurance investigation, here are just a few of the documents that can support your side of the story:
The more documents you can gather to prove your point, the better off you’ll be when trying to win your case.
Legal experts like the team at Gage Mathers Law Group have decades of experience fighting for thousands of car accident cases like yours, resulting in a 99.99% success rate. We know the rights of policyholders during car accident insurance investigations and can make sure you understand what’s going on in the investigation every step of the way. Most importantly, we step in to be your biggest advocate, prevent insurers from overreaching and work hard to get you the outcome you deserve.
Victims of an accident can experience both physical and psychological trauma. Signs of emotional distress include anxiety, panic attacks, depression, insomnia, debilitating fear, social withdrawal, a...
Posted by Joseph D'Aguanno
When you hire a car accident lawyer Phoenix, they will send the insurance company and any other parties responsible for the crash a letter outlining your claims, damages you’ve incurred, and th...
read morePosted by Joseph D'Aguanno
According to the Arizona Department of Transportation, approximately 30% of all motor vehicle accidents in the state result in an injury. The most common car accident injuries include whiplash, b...
read moreIf you or a loved one has been seriously injured, please fill out the form below for your free consultation or call us at (602) 258-0646
(602) 258-0646